|
|
September 2008Words in the NewsThe cover of the July 21 edition of The New Yorker magazine featured Barack and Michelle Obama in a cartoon that became very controversial. The New Yorker editor David Remnick defended it as "satire;" New York's Governor David Paterson condemned it as "feeding the prurient interest of bigoted, prejudiced people in this society." The words satire and prurient were both among the most frequently looked-up words for a few days in the middle of July when the magazine hit the newsstands. Does the cartoon fit the definition of satire, and is it appropriate to call the public's interest prurient? Let's take a look at these two words with cultural stories to tell. The first evidence of use of the word prurient in English goes back to 1592. Prurient derives from the Latin verb prurire, meaning "to itch" or "to crave," and accordingly the adjective prurient meant "marked by restless craving" or "itching with curiosity." That original sense of immoderate or unwholesome interest preceded the use of the word in contexts expressing a specifically sexual interest, more common in current print use. Governor Paterson used the older sense of the word. The Collegiate Encyclopedia offers some background on satire, an artistic form in which individual vices, abuses, or shortcomings are held up to censure by means of ridicule or irony, sometimes with the intent to bring about improvement. Literature and drama are its chief vehicles, but satire is also found in such mediums as film, the visual arts (including caricatures), and, of course, political cartoons. Though present in Greek literature, notably in the works of Aristophanes, satire generally follows the example of either of two Romans, Horace or Juvenal. To Horace, the satirist is an urbane man of the world who sees folly everywhere but is moved to gentle laughter rather than to rage. Juvenal's satirist is an upright man who is horrified and angered by corruption. Their different perspectives produced the subgenres of satire identified by J. Dryden as comic satire and tragic satire. |
